The Best Training Treats for Dogs: High-Value Rewards That Work

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article are Amazon affiliate links. This means we may earn a small commission if you buy — at no extra cost to you.

If you are trying to teach your dog not to lunge at a squirrel using a piece of dry cardboard-flavored kibble, you are going to lose that battle 100% of the time.

When you’re out training in highly distracting environments (like learning how to not pull on the leash), you are competing with the environment. The smells, the other dogs, the kids running around—all of these are highly rewarding to your dog. Your treats need to be more rewarding than those distractions.

This is where “High-Value” treats come in.

The Holy Trinity of a Good Training Treat

To be an effective training treat, the snack must meet these three criteria:

1. Tiny (Pea-sized): Training requires high repetition. If you are rewarding your dog 30 times during a 15-minute walk, the treats must be tiny so they don’t get full, fat, or stop to chew for a minute straight.
2. Soft: Hard biscuits require chewing. Chewing breaks the flow of training and takes their attention away from you. Soft treats can be swallowed instantly so you can keep moving.
3. Smelly: Dogs experience the world through their nose. A highly aromatic scent (like salmon or liver) cuts through the distracting smells of the park.

Top High-Value Treat Recommendations

If you don’t want to carry hot dogs in your pocket (we understand), here are the absolute best commercial options that trainers swear by:

1. Zuke’s Mini Naturals

These are the gold standard for many dog trainers. They are exactly pea-sized, clock in at less than 3 calories per treat, and are incredibly soft and smelly. The Salmon and Peanut Butter flavors are usually massive hits.

🔗 View Zuke’s Mini Naturals on Amazon

2. Freeze-Dried Liver (Any brand)

This is essentially pure doggy crack. Freeze-dried beef or lamb liver has a singular ingredient, high protein, and a smell that will make your dog focus completely. The only downside is they can be crumbly in your pocket, and too much rich liver can sometimes cause soft stool in sensitive dogs, so mix them in with other treats.

🔗 View Stewart Freeze-Dried Liver Treats

3. Pet Botanics Training Rewards

Slightly larger but very easy to break in half. These have a meat-roll consistency that dogs love and come in massive bags that will last you through weeks of intensive anti-pull harness training.

🔗 View Pet Botanics Training Rewards

The “Trail Mix” Trick

If you feed your dog the same super-premium treat every single day, their value decreases. It becomes the new normal.

To keep your dog guessing and engaged, make a “Trail Mix” in your treat pouch. Mix 70% of low-value treats (like their regular kibble) with 30% of high-value treats (like chopped-up hot dog or freeze-dried liver). Let the bag sit overnight so the kibble absorbs the smell of the good stuff.

During the walk, they never know if they’re going to win a piece of kibble, or hit the jackpot with liver. This keeps their motivation incredibly high.